Interview with Javier Bernácer When we tackle the big questions, hyper-specialisation is no way to address them
Javier Bernácer is a neuroscientist and philosopher, and Director of the Master’s Degree in Neuroscience and Humanities, a continuing education programme organised by the International Centre for Neuroscience and Ethics (CINET) of Fundación Tatiana, in partnership with the International University Menéndez Pelayo (UIMP).
The programme brings together a diverse, international faculty and combines a strong academic foundation with an innovative perspective, drawing on neuroscience, philosophy, ethics, artificial intelligence, art and law.
We spoke to Bernácer about the programme, the need for a more interdisciplinary approach to science, the major questions facing neuroscience, the contribution the humanities can make, and the education of future generations of professionals.

Why include the humanities in a master’s degree that aims to explain the brain? It is not the first thing that springs to mind…
The brain is part of the nervous system, which always develops alongside the rest of the body. The body, in turn, is an integral part of the organism’s life history. When we talk about human beings, the brain, the body and the course of a person’s life, including our relationships with our environment, are inseparable. Therefore, to understand the brain properly, we need to understand it as part of the person as a whole.
Some fields of knowledge address the biological or physiological aspects of human beings, while others focus on the mental, historical or relational dimensions. To understand human beings properly, we need to bring all these fields of knowledge back together. Otherwise, we will be left with a fragmented view.
Has hyper-specialisation caused us to lose sight of the person as a whole? What are the consequences for science?
Absolutely. The division of knowledge, which is becoming increasingly pronounced, means that we lose sight of organisms as a whole, particularly human beings, whose complexity is even greater. To a certain extent, highly specialised research is beneficial because it allows us to gain a deeper understanding of specific aspects of reality. However, when we tackle the big questions, hyper-specialisation is no way to address them.
Are there many programmes like this one around the world?
Honestly, no. We can say that this programme is unique in the world. There are few programmes dealing with this subject — the integration of neuroscience and the humanities — and, as far as we know, ours is the only one with this structure: first, complementary training tailored to the student’s field of expertise, followed by training in cutting-edge interdisciplinary topics.
The master’s degree devotes a specific module to the mind–brain problem. Why does this remain one of the great questions of our time?
Because, far from being a purely academic subject, it is something that affects us all very directly. We all experience a sense of tension between our mental activity — our desires, beliefs and decisions — and our biology.
Mental illness provides an extreme example of this: why is it so difficult for me to control an anxiety attack or overcome depressive symptoms?
From an academic perspective, after centuries of reflection on this subject, various positions have been put forward, each with its own advantages and drawbacks. Our aim is for students to reflect on these positions and arrive at the one they find most convincing or, thanks to the well-rounded education they receive, even develop new answers to the problem.
Are you concerned that we are too quick to compare the workings of the brain to those of a computer?
Yes, this is a significant problem. Throughout history, because of its complexity, the brain has always been compared to the leading technological advances of the time. The irony is that researchers in every era have believed their metaphor to be the definitive one.
The computational paradigm of the brain has led to many advances in our understanding of it, but there is a growing sense that it is now hindering research more than helping it.
What other major questions in neuroscience could benefit from insights from the humanities today?
One example is the scientific study of consciousness. To what extent can subjective experience be studied through psychology or neuroscience?
Dialogue is also essential when addressing the ethical challenges posed by emerging neurotechnologies. Is it legitimate to use certain techniques that modify our brains, knowing that they may also affect our mental activity in the short or long term?
The master’s degree also includes modules exploring the role of neuroscience in other areas, such as education, art and, of course, artificial intelligence.
What aspects of human experience can we still not explain solely in terms of neuronal activity?
Phew! I would say all of them! Put another way, we cannot fully explain any aspect of human experience in terms of neuronal activity alone.
The programme aims to foster critical thinking about cutting-edge techniques and their ethical and social implications. Is the idea not to accept something simply because it is new? What other criteria should guide us?
Interventions in neuroscience have always followed a curious trajectory, unlike those in other disciplines. For example, the use of medication for depression, anxiety, attention and so on has, in most cases — perhaps all of them — begun by chance, almost accidentally. And in many instances, we still do not know exactly how these drugs affect the nervous system.
Today, with the use of neurotechnologies, we are once again tempted to start using them first, see what they do, and only then begin to regulate them. This is why broad-based ethical reflection is so important: it allows us to anticipate the problems that lie ahead.
The faculty brings together experts from different fields and universities around the world. What does this diversity offer students, and what kinds of conversations do you expect to emerge between academics who, on paper, speak such different languages?
This is an integral part of interdisciplinary education. However, in my view, what is most important and enriching for students is not simply the opportunity to discuss ideas with professors from very different disciplines, but the fact that these professors actually hold opposing positions on certain issues.
For example, in the module on the mind–brain problem, we have Patricia Churchland, a leading figure in eliminative materialism, alongside strong advocates of dualism, emergentism, Aristotelianism and dual-aspect monism.
Students have benefited enormously from these discussions, but so have the professors, who have congratulated the students on the depth and richness of the debates.
How was the first edition? What kind of students does the programme attract?
It was wonderful. As I said, both students and professors enjoyed the experience and learnt a great deal. Our students came from backgrounds including psychology, neurobiology, philosophy and even astrophysics. They all felt fully integrated into the programme and able to follow the discussions during the second semester.
In fact, despite coming from different parts of the world, they chose to defend their master’s dissertations in person in order to enjoy an even more immersive experience.
If, ten years from now, graduates of this master’s degree had helped change the way we understand the brain and the human person, what would you hope they had achieved?
I would hope they had helped promote a more human-centred vision of neuroscience, both within academia and across society as a whole. Above all, I would want them to have a strong commitment to truth and to the advancement of knowledge as a whole. If they achieve that, everything else will follow naturally.